Curated for Style. Designed for Your Experience.

Attired in a chic palette of whites, blacks, and neutrals, our rooms and suites are outfitted to impress, with Restoration Hardware furnishings, high-thread-count linens, spa-like bathrooms, and other tasteful detailing. It’s like an invite to your well-heeled friends’ euphemistic cottage by the sea – only better. Because we have fresh morning pastries and complimentary snacks in the galley, all day long.

bedroom with white walls and a large bed with white sheets and a gray blanket. The bed has a gray headboard and is accompanied by a white nightstand and a white lamp. A large window is visible on the right side of the room.

Luxurious Accomodations

Rooms & Suites

The Menhaden welcomes you to distinct guest rooms and suites that seamlessly blend our coastal locale and historic setting with modern sophistication. It’s the book thoughtfully placed on your bedside table and that beckons you to escape into its pages. It’s your curtained window, eager to reveal partial water views (available in select rooms) and a subtle reminder of the beauty that awaits. And it’s the driftwood accents that delicately adorn your room, adding soft touches to celebrate our seaside surroundings.

Book Now

Bedroom with white furniture, white walls, and a window with white curtains. The bed has a white comforter and pillows, and there is a bench at the foot of the bed.

Pet-Friendly Rooms & Suites

Your four-legged friends are family, too! We are happy welcome dogs (under 25 pounds) to The Menhaden. Our select pet-friendly rooms offer a cozy place to curl up before a stroll through Greenport, a robust game of fetch on the beach, and a romp through the surf. Please call the Front Desk (631-333-2777) to book a pet-friendly room.

A bedroom with a white bed, a chair, and a mirror. The bed has a white comforter and pillows, with a dark blue blanket at the foot. A chair with a white cushion sits in the corner, and a mirror hangs on the wall to the left of the bed. A painting or photograph hangs above the bed, and a lamp is attached to the wall to the right. The room has white walls and a wooden floor.

ADA Rooms & Suites

Our location may be historic but our interiors are thoroughly updated, to include ADA-accessible rooms with accessible entry, ADA bathrooms, closed-caption TVs, and accessible hotel grounds, including our lobby, restaurant, and common areas. Service animals welcome.

“

“Such a gem! I stayed here during the week and had the best stay. The staff is so nice, the location is great and the hotel itself is so clean and well maintained. This might have been the best hotel experience I have ever had. I did not want to leave so ended up extending my stay. The hotel is in the perfect location and the roof is so relaxing to have a coffee or drink on. The galley is stocked with amazing treats and so convenient as well as the little shop with amazing coffee. I loved biking to the beach and to the wineries. I would not think twice and book this place, you will not be disappointed.”

Sarah L
Tripadvisor