All the Best Places for Oysters on Long Island

July 27, 2023

There’s nothing like indulging in fresh-from-the-sea oysters and a glass of bubbly, especially if you’re doing so right on the water. In recent years, the North Fork of Long Island has become a major destination for oyster lovers in the U.S. You can find and eat great oysters in any season here. For your trip, book a stay at one of the prime boutique hotels on Long Island: the Menhaden. From here, you can explore all the best places to sample these delicious bivalves, plus partake in the hotel’s unique oyster-shucking and tasting experiences.    

Where to Get Oysters on Long Island 

Satisfy your seafood cravings at Little Creek Oyster Farm & Market, located nearly next door to the Menhaden. This tiny “market” by the docks oozes authenticity — it’s part of a local collective that works with dozens of individual farmers and harvesters. While the menu changes with availability, rest assured you’ll always find the freshest oysters imaginable here, in addition to beer, wine, and other snacks. If you want an in-depth look at how oysters are cultivated, check out Widow’s Hole Oyster Company, which is open for tours and tastings. And, go for the Wednesday happy hour at Little Ram Oyster Co., where the selection of local bivalves, speciality cocktails, and “sea-cuterie” trays draws locals and tourists alike.   

 

Aside from being one of the best Greenport Village hotels, the Menhaden offers several bespoke experiences to guests that center around oysters. Sign up for the Founders Oyster Experience, where you’ll take a tour on an oyster boat and learn how to properly shuck an oyster. The Private Oyster Charter is a six-person yacht tour that cruises Peconic Bay, Shelter Island, and Sunset Beach (you also get complimentary oysters and a bottle of champagne). Finally, as part of the Rose and Oyster Happy Hour experience, take a private oyster shucking class with a local farmer while sipping rose on the hotel’s rooftop deck.    

 

Plan a Stay at the Menhaden

Whether you’re looking for Long Island getaways for couples, families, or solo travelers, the Menhaden makes for the ideal place to hole up for a while. Inspired by the bucolic coastal surroundings, this lovely North Fork boutique hotel hits the sweet spot between upscale luxury and cozy comfort. You’ll love hanging out here after a day of oyster-tasting — catch a gorgeous sunset over the harbor on the rooftop bar, and then enjoy the comfort and privacy of your room, outfitted with chic furnishings and black-and-white details. Thanks to its convenient (and beautiful) location and luxe amenities, the Menhaden is easily one of the top places to stay in Greenport, NY.